Page 4 - Churches in Shelter Island, NY
23 denominations including Catholic, Episcopal, and Methodist (UMC)
FaithStreet makes it easy to find a church that feels like home. Whether you're new to the area or exploring your faith, our directory features 3 churches in Shelter Island, plus over 90 more nearby—big or small, traditional or modern, denominational or nondenominational.
Explore churches of all sizes, from small and intimate to large and vibrant. Whether you prefer traditional services, modern worship, or something in between, you'll find options to match your needs.
Not sure where to start? Use FaithStreet to discover churches by size, worship style, or programs. Begin your search today and find a welcoming church community in Shelter Island.
Churches near Shelter Island, NY
Search102 churches near Shelter Island, NY
-
Most Holy Trinity Catholic Church
Catholic · East Hampton, NY · 10 mi -
Grace Presbyterian Church
Presbyterian (PCA) · Water Mill, NY · 10 miGrace Presbyterian Church began in 2007 as a church plant of Redeemer Presbyterian Church (PCA) in Manhattan, NY. By God's grace we exist to see Long Island awakened t...
-
Beacon of the C&MA
Christian and Missionary Alliance · Water Mill, NY · 10 mi
-
First United Methodist Church of East Hampton
Methodist (UMC) · East Hampton, NY · 10 mi
-
St. Peter's Chapel
Episcopal · East Hampton, NY · 11 mi
-
St Michael Lutheran Church
Lutheran (ELCA) · Amagansett, NY · 12 mi
-
Amagansett Church of the Nazarene
Church of the Nazarene · Amagansett, NY · 12 mi
-
St. Thomas' Chapel
Episcopal · Amagansett, NY · 12 mi
-
St. Peter's Catholic Church
Catholic · Amagansett, NY · 12 mi
-
Church of the Redeemer
Episcopal · Mattituck, NY · 12 mi
Showing 31–40 of 102 churches