Grace Presbyterian Church

A place to experience grow in God's grace. Water Mill, NY
Grace Presbyterian Church

Plan Your Visit

1225 Montauk Highway
Water Mill, NY 11976



Get directions on Google Maps

Who We Are

Grace Presbyterian Church began in 2007 as a church plant of Redeemer Presbyterian Church (PCA) in Manhattan, NY. By God's grace we exist to see Long Island awakened to the glory of Jesus Christ.
While we serve all of the Hamptons we also have members who live over 30 miles away.
We are made up of people of different socio-economic backgrounds. In addition, some are longtime followers of Christ; some are new Christians; while others are investigating who Jesus is and what he means to them.
Some of the comments we have heard from visitors are: "It's friendly here," "I'm free to doubt," "It feels alive," "The sermon seemed like it was directed at me," and "There are lots of young families with kids."

About Us

Presbyterian (PCA)




Mark Middlekauff

Mark Middlekauff

Rev. Mark Middlekauff grew up in St. Louis, MO, so he is a huge Cardinals fan. Not growing up in a Christian home he came to faith at the age of 29 while running a computer business he started. He soon began volunteering in the youth ministry at his church. There he met his wife, Lesley, and sold his business and worked full time in youth ministry while attending Covenant Theological Seminary. He graduated in 2005 with an MDiv and answered a call from Redeemer Presbyterian Church to plant a new church in the Hamptons which is now Grace Presbyterian Church. He lives in Southampton with Lesley and their 3 daughters. He enjoys cycling, fishing, playing the drums, and well-aged scotch.

What Members Say Add your voice

Go here? Tell us why you love Grace Presbyterian Church. Visited? Tell us what a newcomer can expect.