Penn Yan Churches

Looking for a church in Penn Yan? FaithStreet makes it easy to find a church that feels like home. Whether you’re new to the area or exploring your faith, our directory features over 20 churches in Penn Yan. You’ll find many conservative, friendly, and casual churches—big or small, traditional or modern, denominational or nondenominational.

Popular worship music styles include contemporary, traditional hymns, and passionate reverent, offering something for every preference. Churches here often offer programs like children's ministry, nursery, adult education, missions, and seniors ministry, helping you connect and grow.

Not sure where to start? Use FaithStreet to discover churches by size, worship style, or programs. Begin your search today and find a welcoming church community in Penn Yan.

Learn more

Churches

68 churches near Penn Yan, NY

American Baptist Churches USA in Penn Yan, NY

1. Potter Baptist Church
Sunday Services

10:00am
Episcopal in Penn Yan, NY

2. St. Mark's Church
American Baptist Churches USA in Penn Yan, NY

3. First Baptist Church
Lutheran (ELCA) in Penn Yan, NY

4. St Paul Lutheran Church
Sunday Services

08:00am

10:45am
Church of the Nazarene in Penn Yan, NY

5. Penn Yan White Stone Chapel Church of the Nazarene
Lots of kids, Down to Earth

Adult Education, Children's Ministry

Traditional Hymns, Contemporary

Sunday Services

10:00am

11:00am
Nondenominational in Penn Yan, NY

6. Penn Yan Bible Church
Conservative, Casual

Missions, Adult Education

Traditional Hymns, Contemporary

Sunday Services

10:00am
Episcopal in Branchport, NY

7. St. Luke's Episcopal Church
Sunday Services

09:30am
Christian Congregation in Willard, NY

8. Rapture Preparation Church
Presbyterian (PCUSA) in Geneva, NY

9. West Fayette Presbyterian Church
Sunday Services

09:00am
Methodist (UMC) in Penn Yan, NY

10. Bluff Point United Methodist Church
Methodist (UMC) in Penn Yan, NY

11. Penn Yan United Methodist Church
Methodist (UMC) in Penn Yan, NY

12. Milo Center United Methodist Church
American Baptist Churches USA in Penn Yan, NY

13. Lake Keuka Baptist Church
American Baptist Churches USA in Penn Yan, NY

14. Second Milo Baptist Church
Catholic in Penn Yan, NY

15. St. Michael Catholic Church
Baptist (SBC) in Penn Yan, NY

16. The Haven Baptist Fellowship
General Association of Regular Baptist Churches in Penn Yan, NY

17. Emmanuel Baptist Church
Assemblies of God in Geneva, NY

18. Assembly of God
Nondenominational in Geneva, NY

19. The Harbor
Methodist (UMC) in Penn Yan, NY

20. Yatesville United Methodist Church