Bethel (Bay Shore) A.M.E. Church
About Us
AME Church
Bethel A.M.E. Church Bay Shore is the church that makes a difference by making people different! We are a community of believers who seek to make a positive difference in the world. Our mission is to make people different by sharing the love and teachings of Jesus Christ. We welcome all who are seeking a deeper connection with God and others.
We offer various services and programs for all ages to help build a stronger relationship with God and our community.
- Vibe
- Down to Earth, Spirit-filled, Friendly, Inclusive, Charismatic, Multigenerational, Young families, Lively, Neighborhood-focused
- Programs
- Community Service, Faith and Work, Missions, Food Pantry
- Denomination
- African Methodist Episcopal Church
- Size
- Small
- Founded
- 1897
Contact Information
Our Services
Service Times
- Tuesday
-
- 07:00pm
- Weekly Tuesday Night Service
- Sunday
-
- 11:15am
- Worship Service
What to Expect
Leadership

Tyra L Frazier
Meet Reverend Tyra L. Frazier, a dedicated leader and current Senior Pastor at Bethel AME Church in Bay Shore, New York. Born and raised in Kansas City, Missouri, Rev. Frazier has a profound commitment to justice and ministry. She holds a Bachelor’s degree in Administration of Justice from the University of Missouri - Kansas City and is a certified Court Appointed Special Advocate in Missouri. Her theological education includes a Master of Arts in Christian Ministries from Liberty University, obtained in May 2018, and a Master of Divinity from the Rawlings School of Divinity, completed in May 2022. Rev. Frazier’s ministerial journey began at the Greater Allen Cathedral of New York under the mentorship of Rev. Dr. Elaine Flake. She further honed her pastoral skills as the Executive Minister to Rev. Stephen Michael Lewis at Bethel AME Church in Freeport, NY. Her preaching debut was on June 11, 2016, with a sermon titled “Let’s Go to Samaria,” which marked her licensing in the African Methodist Episcopal Church. She was ordained as an Itinerant Deacon in December 2021 and as an Itinerant Elder in April 2022 during the 200th Session of the New York Annual Conference. Prior to her current role, she served as pastor at Morris Brown AME Church in Queens, New York, and Bethel AME Church in York, PA. Rev. Frazier finds deep inspiration in her favorite scripture, 1 Peter 5:10, which speaks to the resilience and grace provided by God. She warmly invites everyone to Bethel AME Church, where she leads with compassion and an open heart, guiding the community through spiritual growth and collective empowerment. Join us to experience her uplifting sermons and welcoming spirit.Location & Directions
What Members Say
Add your voiceCreate an account or sign in to save your experience.
Go here? Tell us why you love Bethel (Bay Shore) A.M.E. Church. Visited? Tell us what a newcomer can expect.