Churches in Stillwater, NJ

34 denominations including Methodist (UMC), Catholic, and Episcopal

FaithStreet makes it easy to find a church that feels like home. Whether you're new to the area or exploring your faith, our directory features 2 churches in Stillwater, plus over 190 more nearby—big or small, traditional or modern, denominational or nondenominational.

Explore churches of all sizes, from small and intimate to large and vibrant. Whether you prefer traditional services, modern worship, or something in between, you'll find options to match your needs.

Not sure where to start? Use FaithStreet to discover churches by size, worship style, or programs. Begin your search today and find a welcoming church community in Stillwater.

Churches near Stillwater, NJ

Search

197 churches near Stillwater, NJ

Harmony Hill United Methodist Church

1. Harmony Hill United Methodist Church

Methodist (UMC) · Stillwater, NJ · 2.6 mi
First Presbyterian Church

2. First Presbyterian Church

Presbyterian (PCUSA) · Stillwater, NJ · 5490.2 mi
Our Lady of Mount Carmel Catholic Church

3. Our Lady of Mount Carmel Catholic Church

Catholic · , · 2 mi
St. Joseph Catholic Church

4. St. Joseph Catholic Church

Catholic · Newton, NJ · 4 mi
First United Methodist Church of Newton

5. First United Methodist Church of Newton

Methodist (UMC) · Newton, NJ · 6 mi
Marksboro Community Church

6. Marksboro Community Church

Assemblies of God · Blairstown, NJ · 6 mi

Newcomers welcome

We are a friendly congregation meeting in Warren County in Northwest New Jersey. We are striving to live the Christian life with love. We want to reach out to you ...
New Horizons Church of the Nazarene

7. New Horizons Church of the Nazarene

Church of the Nazarene · Newton, NJ · 7 mi
Holy Spirit Christian Fellowship Church

8. Holy Spirit Christian Fellowship Church

Assemblies of God · Newton, NJ · 7 mi
Johnsonburg United Methodist Church

9. Johnsonburg United Methodist Church

Methodist (UMC) · Johnsonburg, NJ · 7 mi
Redeemer Lutheran Church

10. Redeemer Lutheran Church

Lutheran (LCMS) · Newton, NJ · 8 mi

“Nothing at this time.......There is a possibility that I may go live my last years with my son in Sandyston and I wanted to see if there was a conserva...” — Attender

1 experience

Load More Churches

Showing 10 of 197 churches in total

Explore more churches

Explore Stillwater, NJ Churches by Denomination

View all Stillwater denominations

A

B

C

E

G

L

M

N

O

P

R

S

U

W

A

B

Baptist (SBC) 4

C

E

G

General Association of Regular Baptist Churches 2

L

Lutheran (ELCA) 8
Lutheran (LCMS) 6

M

Methodist (UMC) 48

N

O

Orthodox 2

P

Presbyterian (EPC) 2

R

Reformed (RCA) 2

S

Seventh-day Adventist 7

U

United Church of Christ 2

W

Wesleyan 2

Explore Churches in Nearby Cities

View all New Jersey churches

A

B

C

E

H

I

J

N

P

S

U

A

Allentown, PA 166

B

Bethlehem, PA 103
Bayonne, NJ 47

C

Clifton, NJ 51

E

H

Hackensack, NJ 42

I

Irvington, NJ 41

J

Jersey City, NJ 143

N

Newark, NJ 212
New Brunswick, NJ 63

P

S

Scranton, PA 92
Spring Valley, NY 36

U

Union City, NJ 40

Recently Viewed

Open Church

E. Northport, NY
Fuente De Vida Eterna

Tampa, FL
Redemption Christian Center

Denver, CO
Lincoln Center

Lincoln, ME