Oyster Bay Churches

Looking for a church in Oyster Bay? FaithStreet makes it easy to find a church that feels like home. Whether you’re new to the area or exploring your faith, our directory features over 10 churches in Oyster Bay. You’ll find many spirit-filled, friendly, and charismatic churches—big or small, traditional or modern, denominational or nondenominational.

Popular worship music styles include contemporary and passionate reverent, offering something for every preference. Churches here often offer programs like community service, children's ministry, and missions, helping you connect and grow.

Not sure where to start? Use FaithStreet to discover churches by size, worship style, or programs. Begin your search today and find a welcoming church community in Oyster Bay.

Learn more

Churches

452 churches near Oyster Bay, NY

Seventh-day Adventist in Wyandanch, NY

1. Macedonia Seventh-day Adventist Church
Neighborhood-focused, Spirit-filled

Faith and Work, Youth Group

Praise and Worship, Traditional Hymns
Catholic in Hicksville, NY

2. Our Lady of Mercy Catholic Church
Nondenominational in Syosset, NY

3. upward church
Down to Earth, Lively

Addiction/Recovery, Nursery

Contemporary

Sunday Services

03:00pm
Presbyterian in Plainview , NY

4. Assurance Presbyterian church
Lutheran (ELCA) in Hicksville, NY

5. St Stephen's Lutheran Church
Traditional Liturgy, Spirit-filled

Contemporary, Traditional Hymns

Sunday Services

08:00am

10:30am
Methodist (UMC) in Hicksville, NY

6. Hicksville United Methodist Church
Independent in Hicksville, NY

7. Cornerstone Christian Church of Ll
Sunday Services

10:00am

11:00am

05:30pm
Lutheran (ELCA) in Syosset, NY

8. Faith Lutheran Church
Multigenerational, Friendly

Young Adults, Social Justice

Traditional Hymns, Organ

Sunday Services

10:00am

07:00pm
Church of God (Anderson, IN) in Westbury, NY

9. Westbury Divine Church of God
United Church of Christ in Syosset, NY

10. Community Church of Syosset (U.C.C.)
Seventh-day Adventist in Westbury, NY

11. Beer-Scheba French Seventh-day Adventist Mission
Lutheran (LCMS) in Bethpage , NY

12. St Paul Evangelical Lutheran Church
Episcopal in Syosset, NY

13. St. Bede's Episcopal Church
Community Service

Sunday Services

09:00am
Episcopal in Plainview, NY

14. St. Margaret's Episcopal Church
Traditional Liturgy, Multigenerational

Addiction/Recovery, Faith and Work

Organ, Praise and Worship

Sunday Services

10:00am
Baptist in Westbury, NY

15. CrossBridge Church
Episcopal in Westbury, NY

16. Church of the Advent
Baptist in Bethpage, NY

17. Plainedge Baptist Church
Catholic in Westbury, NY

18. St. Andrew the Apostle
Community Service, Adult Education

Sunday Services

08:00am

09:00am
Presbyterian (PCUSA) in Levittown, NY

19. The First Presbyterian Church of Levittown
Sunday Services

10:00am
Methodist (UMC) in East Meadow, NY

20. United Methodist Church of East Meadow
Sunday Services

09:00am