Churches in New Buffalo, MI

Discover casual, creative, and down to earth churches

FaithStreet makes it easy to find a church that feels like home. Whether you're new to the area or exploring your faith, our directory features 9 churches in New Buffalo, plus over 120 more nearby—big or small, traditional or modern, denominational or nondenominational.

Popular worship music styles include traditional hymns and organ, offering something for every preference. Churches here often offer programs like social justice, addiction/recovery, and choir, helping you connect and grow.

Not sure where to start? Use FaithStreet to discover churches by size, worship style, or programs. Begin your search today and find a welcoming church community in New Buffalo.

Churches near New Buffalo, MI

Search

132 churches near New Buffalo, MI

First United Methodist Church of New Buffalo

1. First United Methodist Church of New Buffalo

Methodist (UMC) · New Buffalo, MI · 0.1 mi
Saint John United Church of Christ

2. Saint John United Church of Christ

United Church of Christ · New Buffalo, MI · 0.2 mi

LGBTQ+ friendly · Newcomers welcome

We area church that is open and loving, and accepting of all people; no matter your race, ethnicity, or sexual orientation you are always welcome here! We truly believ...
Bible Baptist Church

3. Bible Baptist Church

Independent Baptist · New Buffalo, MI · 0.2 mi
St. Mary of the Lake Catholic Church

4. St. Mary of the Lake Catholic Church

Catholic · New Buffalo, MI · 0.4 mi
Journey Lutheran Church of Harbor County

5. Journey Lutheran Church of Harbor County

Lutheran (LCMS) · New Buffalo, MI · 0.7 mi
Lighthouse Village

6. Lighthouse Village

Church of God (Cleveland, TN) · New Buffalo, MI · 1.2 mi
Grace Baptist Church

7. Grace Baptist Church

Independent Baptist · New Buffalo, MI
St. Mary of the Lake Parish

8. St. Mary of the Lake Parish

New Buffalo, MI · 5830.5 mi
Annunciation & Agia Paraskevi

9. Annunciation & Agia Paraskevi

Orthodox (Greek) · New Buffalo, MI
Michigan City Foursquare Church

10. Michigan City Foursquare Church

Foursquare · Michigan City, IN · 5 mi

Load More Churches

Showing 10 of 132 churches in total

Explore more churches

What to expect visiting New Buffalo, MI Churches

New Buffalo, MI church responds to "What if I'm not a Christian?"

We accept and affirm all people's choices in life.

Saint John United Church of Christ

Explore New Buffalo, MI Churches by Denomination

View all New Buffalo denominations

A

B

C

D

E

F

I

L

M

N

P

S

U

A

B

Baptist (SBC) 2

C

D

Disciples of Christ 1

E

Episcopal 7

F

Foursquare 2

I

Independent Baptist 5

L

Lutheran (ELCA) 3
Lutheran (LCMS) 7

M

Methodist (UMC) 12

N

Nondenominational 10

P

S

Seventh-day Adventist 4

U

United Church of Christ 4

Explore Churches in Nearby Cities

View all Michigan churches

B

C

E

G

H

L

M

N

P

S

V

B

Benton Harbor, MI 34

C

Chicago, IL 1,601
Crown Point, IN 45

E

Elkhart, IN 108
East Chicago, IN 30

G

Gary, IN 117
Goshen, IN 84

H

L

La Porte, IN 49

M

N

Niles, MI 44

P

Portage, IN 40
Plymouth, IN 36

S

South Bend, IN 174
South Holland, IL 29

V

Valparaiso, IN 63