Monticello Churches

Looking for a church in Monticello? FaithStreet makes it easy to find a church that feels like home. Whether you’re new to the area or exploring your faith, our directory features over 10 churches in Monticello. Discover a variety of churches here—big or small, traditional or modern, denominational or nondenominational.

Explore churches of all sizes, from small and intimate to large and vibrant. Whether you prefer traditional services, modern worship, or something in between, you’ll find options to match your needs.

Not sure where to start? Use FaithStreet to discover churches by size, worship style, or programs. Begin your search today and find a welcoming church community in Monticello.

Learn more

Churches

45 churches near Monticello, NY

Catholic in Monticello, NY

1. St. Peter's Catholic Church
Baptist (SBC) in Monticello, NY

2. New Salem Baptist Church of Sullivan County
Methodist (UMC) in Kauneonga Lake, NY

3. Kauneonga Lake Community United Methodist Church
Live Stream

Sunday Services

10:00am

10:00am

10:00am

10:00am
Pentecostal in LIBERTY, NY

4. LIGHTHOUSE MINISTRIES
Assemblies of God in Woodbourne, NY

5. Crossway Assembly of God
Young, Lots of kids

Missions, Children's Ministry

Contemporary, Praise and Worship

Sunday Services

10:30am
Presbyterian (PCUSA) in Liberty, NY

6. First Presbyterian Church
Episcopal in Monticello, NY

7. St. John's Episcopal Church
Assemblies of God in Monticello, NY

8. Mahanaim Pentecostal Church
Methodist (UMC) in Monticello, NY

9. Monticello United Methodist Church
Assemblies of God in , NY

10.
Church of God (Cleveland, TN) in Monticello, NY

11. Word of Life New Testament
Monticello, NY

12. Iglesia de Dios Monticello :: Church of God Monticello
Seventh-day Adventist in Monticello, NY

13. Monticello Seventh-day Adventist Church
Pentecostal (PCAF) in Monticello, New York

14. Bethlehem Temple Church
Church of the Nazarene in Rock Hill, NY

15. Rock Hill Church of the Nazarene
Methodist (UMC) in Rock Hill, NY

16. Rock Hill United Methodist Church
Methodist (UMC) in Woodridge, NY

17. Woodridge United Methodist Church
Church of God (Cleveland, TN) in Woodridge, NY

18. Nuevo Pacto
Methodist (UMC) in Hurleyville, NY

19. Hurleyville United Methodist Church
Lutheran (ELCA) in Harlemville, NY

20. Emanuel Lutheran Church