Middlebury Churches

Looking for a church in Middlebury? FaithStreet makes it easy to find a church that feels like home. Whether you’re new to the area or exploring your faith, our directory features over 10 churches in Middlebury. Discover a variety of churches here—big or small, traditional or modern, denominational or nondenominational.

Explore churches of all sizes, from small and intimate to large and vibrant. Whether you prefer traditional services, modern worship, or something in between, you’ll find options to match your needs.

Not sure where to start? Use FaithStreet to discover churches by size, worship style, or programs. Begin your search today and find a welcoming church community in Middlebury.

Learn more

Churches

201 churches near Middlebury, IN

Missionary Church in Middlebury, IN

1. Crystal Valley Missionary Church
Sunday Services

09:30am
Methodist (UMC) in Bristol, IN

2. Bristol United Methodist Church
Church of the Brethren in Goshen, IN

3. Little Pine Church of the Brethren
Sunday Services

09:30am

10:45am
Missionary Church in Bristol, IN

4. Bristol Missionary Church
Conservative, Progressive

Youth Group, Nursery

Contemporary
Missionary Church in Goshen, IN

5. Bethel Missionary Church
Conservative, Old-school

Adult Education, Youth Group

Traditional Hymns, Contemporary

Sunday Services

10:30am
Mennonite (Reformed) in Goshen, IN

6. Iglesia Menonita del Buen Pastor
Sunday Services

10:00am
Baptist (SBC) in Bristol, IN

7. Elkhart Community Baptist Church
Sunday Services

10:30am
Lutheran (ELCA) in Bristol, IN

8. Zion Lutheran Church
Sunday Services

09:30am
Church of the Nazarene in White Pigeon, MI

9. Lighthouse Community Church of the Nazarene
Nondenominational in Goshen, IN

10. Goshen Christian Church
Multigenerational, Casual

Children's Ministry, Missions

Traditional Hymns, Hillsong-style

Sunday Services

09:00am

10:15am
Evangelical Free Church of America in Goshen, IN

11. River Oaks Community Church
Nondenominational in Goshen,

12. Spirit of Faith Fellowship
Sunday Services

10:30am
Nondenominational in Elkhart, IN

13. Elijah's Fire International Church
Down to Earth, Casual

Missions, Youth Group

Contemporary

Sunday Services

09:30am
Methodist (UMC) in Dowagiac, MI

14. Central United Methodist Church of Ashton
Grace Communion International in Elkhart, IN

15. Grace Family Fellowship
Multigenerational, Casual

Community Service, Children's Ministry

Traditional Hymns, Contemporary

Sunday Services

10:00am
Lutheran (ELCA) in Constantine, MI

16. Messiah Evangelical Lutheran Church
Friendly, Neighborhood-focused

Seniors Ministry, Community Service

Traditional Hymns, Contemporary
Christian and Missionary Alliance in Elkhart, IN

17. Fresh Start Church
Baptist in Elkhart, IN

18. McCoy Memorial Baptist Church
Conservative, Casual

Children's Ministry, Nursery

Traditional Hymns, Hillsong-style

Sunday Services

09:30am

06:00pm
Baptist (GABC) in Elkhart, IN

19. Riverview General Baptist
Pentecostal (UPCI) in Elkhart, IN

20. Life Tabernacle Church Inc
Conservative, Progressive

Children's Ministry, Youth Group

Passionate Reverent, Contemporary

Sunday Services

10:00am

11:30am