Churches in Jay, NY

11 denominations including Methodist (UMC), Catholic, and Episcopal

FaithStreet makes it easy to find a church that feels like home. Whether you're new to the area or exploring your faith, our directory features 1 church in Jay, plus over 40 more nearby—big or small, traditional or modern, denominational or nondenominational.

Explore churches of all sizes, from small and intimate to large and vibrant. Whether you prefer traditional services, modern worship, or something in between, you'll find options to match your needs.

Not sure where to start? Use FaithStreet to discover churches by size, worship style, or programs. Begin your search today and find a welcoming church community in Jay.

Churches near Jay, NY

Search

50 churches near Jay, NY

First Baptist Church

1. First Baptist Church

American Baptist Churches USA · Jay, NY · 3.6 mi
Calvary Baptist Church

2. Calvary Baptist Church

General Association of Regular Baptist Churches · Wilmington, NY · 5 mi
Whiteface Community United Methodist Church

3. Whiteface Community United Methodist Church

Methodist (UMC) · Wilmington, NY · 5 mi
Wilmington Church of the Nazarene

4. Wilmington Church of the Nazarene

Church of the Nazarene · Wilmington, NY · 5 mi
St. James' Church

5. St. James' Church

Episcopal · Au Sable Forks, NY · 6 mi
AuSable Forks United Methodist Church

6. AuSable Forks United Methodist Church

Methodist (UMC) · Ausable Forks, NY · 7 mi
Clintonville United Methodist Church

7. Clintonville United Methodist Church

Methodist (UMC) · Au Sable Forks, NY · 7 mi
Holy Name Catholic Church

8. Holy Name Catholic Church

Catholic · Au Sable Forks, NY · 7 mi
First Congregational Church of Lewis

9. First Congregational Church of Lewis

United Church of Christ · Lewis, NY · 8 mi
St. Margaret Catholic Church

10. St. Margaret Catholic Church

Catholic · Wilmington, NY · 9 mi

Load More Churches

Showing 10 of 50 churches in total

Explore more churches

Explore Jay, NY Churches by Denomination

View all Jay denominations

A

B

C

E

G

I

M

N

U

A

American Baptist Churches USA 2

B

Baptist (SBC) 2

C

E

Episcopal 6

G

General Association of Regular Baptist Churches 1

I

Independent Baptist 1

M

Methodist (UMC) 14

N

Nondenominational 3

U

United Church of Christ 5

Explore Churches in Nearby Cities

View all New York churches

B

C

E

H

K

L

M

P

S

T

W

B

Burlington, VT 37
Brandon, VT 9

C

Colchester, VT 11
Chateaugay, NY 7

E

Essex Junction, VT 18

H

Hinesburg, VT 6

K

Keeseville, NY 6

L

Lake Placid, NY 9

M

P

Plattsburgh, NY 28
Peru, NY 7

S

T

Ticonderoga, NY 8
Tupper Lake, NY 6

W

Williston, VT 12
Winooski, VT 6

Recently Viewed

Lord's Tabernacle Christian

Memphis, TN
Second Congregational Church

Peabody, MA
The Well MTC

Mount Clemens, MI
River's Edge Bible Fellowship

Pecatonica, IL