Cutchogue Churches

Looking for a church in Cutchogue? FaithStreet makes it easy to find a church that feels like home. Whether you’re new to the area or exploring your faith, our directory features over 10 churches in Cutchogue. You’ll find many casual, friendly, and inclusive churches—big or small, traditional or modern, denominational or nondenominational.

Popular worship music styles include traditional hymns, contemporary, and praise and worship, offering something for every preference. Churches here often offer programs like community service, preschool, food pantry, adult education, and faith and work, helping you connect and grow.

Not sure where to start? Use FaithStreet to discover churches by size, worship style, or programs. Begin your search today and find a welcoming church community in Cutchogue.

Learn more

Churches

74 churches near Cutchogue, NY

Methodist (UMC) in Cutchogue, NY

1. North Fork United Methodist Church
Inclusive, Multigenerational

Nursery, Food Pantry

Praise and Worship, Organ

Sunday Services

10:00am
Episcopal in Mattituck, NY

2. Church of the Redeemer
Lutheran (LCMS) in Aquebogue, NY

3. Our Redeemer Lutheran Church
Sunday Services

08:00am

10:00am
Nondenominational in Riverhead, NY

4. Living Water Church Riverhead
Lots of kids, Friendly

Dance, Nursery

Passionate Reverent, Contemporary
Catholic in Southampton, NY

5. Our Lady of Poland Catholic Church
Presbyterian (PCA) in Water Mill, NY

6. Grace Presbyterian Church
Unitarian Universalist in Bridgehampton, NY

7. Unitarian Universalist Congregation of the South Fork
Casual

Nursery, Social Justice

Sunday Services

10:30am
Presbyterian (PCUSA) in Bridgehampton, NY

8. The Presbyterian Church of Bridgehampton
Sunday Services

10:30am
Nondenominational in Wainscott, NY

9. Hamptons Church
Friendly, Casual

Food Pantry, Children's Ministry

Praise and Worship

Sunday Services

10:00am
Catholic in Cutchogue, NY

10. Our Lady of Ostrabrama Catholic Church
Catholic in Cutchogue, NY

11. Sacred Heart Catholic Church
Catholic in Mattituck, NY

12. Our Lady of Good Counsel Catholic Church
Lutheran (ELCA) in Mattituck, NY

13. Advent Lutheran Church
American Baptist Churches USA in Mattituck, NY

14. Unity Baptist Church
Assemblies of God in Mattituck, NY

15. Iglesia La Nueva Jerusalen
Catholic in ,

16. St. Patrick Catholic Church
United Church of Christ in Northville, NY

17. First Parish Church
United Church of Christ in Aquebogue, NY

18. Old Steeple Community Church
Catholic in Shelter Island, NY

19. Our Lady of the Isle Catholic Church
Catholic in Greenport, NY

20. St. Agnes Catholic Church

Churches Nearby

Discovery

Mobile App

Giving

Cutchogue Churches

Churches

Explore Churches in Nearby Cities

C

D

E

F

G