Churches in Amityville, NY

Discover traditional liturgy, progressive, and gay affirming churches

FaithStreet makes it easy to find a church that feels like home. Whether you're new to the area or exploring your faith, our directory features 23 churches in Amityville, plus over 50 more nearby—big or small, traditional or modern, denominational or nondenominational.

Explore churches of all sizes, from small and intimate to large and vibrant. Whether you prefer traditional services, modern worship, or something in between, you'll find options to match your needs.

Not sure where to start? Use FaithStreet to discover churches by size, worship style, or programs. Begin your search today and find a welcoming church community in Amityville.

Churches near Amityville, NY

Search

79 churches near Amityville, NY

First United Methodist Church, Amityville NY

1. First United Methodist Church, Amityville NY

Methodist (UMC) · Amityville, NY · 0.1 mi

LGBTQ+ friendly · Newcomers welcome

We are an intergenerational congregation with something for everyone. Whether it is the weekly handbell choir or adult choir, the frequent musical offerings from our c...
Saint Mary's Church

2. Saint Mary's Church

Anglican · Amityville, NY · 0.3 mi
Church emmanuel of long island

3. Church emmanuel of long island

Amityville, NY · 0.5 mi
Emanuel Church

4. Emanuel Church

Nondenominational · Amityville, NY · 0.5 mi
Saint Paul Lutheran Church

5. Saint Paul Lutheran Church

Lutheran (LCMS) · Amityville, NY · 0.5 mi
St. Mary's Church

6. St. Mary's Church

Episcopal · Amityville, NY · 0.5 mi
St. Martin of Tours Catholic Church

7. St. Martin of Tours Catholic Church

Catholic · Amityville, NY · 0.8 mi
First Baptist Church of Farmingdale

8. First Baptist Church of Farmingdale

American Baptist Churches USA · Amityville, NY · 1.1 mi
Simpson United Methodist Church

9. Simpson United Methodist Church

Methodist (UMC) · Amityville, NY · 1.4 mi
Ephraim French Seventh-day Adventist Church

10. Ephraim French Seventh-day Adventist Church

Seventh-day Adventist · Amityville, NY · 1.6 mi

Load More Churches

Showing 10 of 79 churches in total

Explore more churches

What to expect visiting Amityville, NY Churches

Amityville, NY church responds to "What if I'm not a Christian?"

You are welcome! Whether you are new to faith, have a lot of experience, or coming back, we welcome you!

First United Methodist Church, Amityville NY in Amityville,NY

First United Methodist Church, Amityville NY

Explore Amityville, NY Churches by Denomination

View all Amityville denominations

A

C

E

L

M

N

S

A

C

Catholic 1
Church of God in Christ 1

E

Episcopal 1

L

Lutheran (LCMS) 1

M

Methodist (UMC) 2

N

S

Seventh-day Adventist 2

Explore Churches in Nearby Cities

View all New York churches

B

C

E

F

H

I

J

M

N

P

S

W

Y

B

Bridgeport, CT 143
Bayonne, NJ 47

C

Clifton, NJ 51

E

Elizabeth, NJ 93
East Orange, NJ 48

F

Fresh Kills, NY 98

H

Hempstead, NY 48
Hackensack, NJ 42

I

Irvington, NJ 41

J

Jersey City, NJ 143

M

Mount Vernon, NY 50

N

P

S

Stamford, CT 95

W

White Plains, NY 61

Y

Yonkers, NY 104

Recently Viewed

Stonebridge Church

Nixa, MO
Iglesia Pentecostal

Verona, MO
Martha's Vineyard Friends

Edgartown, MA
Trinity United Methodist Church

Ralston, NE
St. Peter A.M.E. Church

Delhi, LA
Beech Ridge Baptist Church

Walker, LA
First Baptist Church

Benton, IL
Dunson United Methodist Church

Lagrange, GA
Trinity Lutheran Church

Sidney, NE
St. Alban's Cathedral

Oviedo, FL
St. Gregory Mission

, PA
Covenant Community Fellowship

Canton, IL