Are Most Evangelicals Pro-Israel? Survey Results May Surprise You — and Show a Way Forward

Evangelicals are not as unwavering in their support of Israel as everyone seems to think. That could be good news for the future of Israel.

Nobody ever said it out loud at the church I attended in high school. But the message was clear. If you are a good Christian, if you believe the Bible, if you love Jesus, you are “pro-Israel.” And I was. And I am. Who wants to be anti-anyone?

The challenge facing many American evangelicals and their church leaders, though, is parsing the concept out. What precisely do we mean when we say we are  “pro-Israel”? What does somebody who is pro-Israel think and do? And how does their thinking and doing shape the face of the conflict in Israel-Palestine,* for better or worse?

Most evangelical pastors don’t know, and have never met, an Israeli, let alone heard his or her unique perspective on the challenges facing their nation’s security and identity.

I took my first trip to the region in the fall of 2008. It was transformative on multiple levels and ultimately launched five years of dissertation research on how United States evangelical church leaders think about Israelis and Palestinians and how those views influence their churches’ activity, or lack thereof, in the Middle East.

Part of my research included a fairly comprehensive anonymous online survey that produced data from 297 US church leaders who self-identify as “evangelical.” I expected the survey to confirm the assumption that U.S. evangelicals, because they lean right-of-center both theologically and politically, are card-carrying members of the “pro-Israel” camp.

It does. And it doesn’t. What I find intrigues me.

A significant population of U.S. evangelicals are rejecting false dichotomy thinking on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

Indeed, 70 percent of church leaders describe their churches as both theologically and politically conservative. However, when asked, “Who do you sympathize with more in the current conflict in Israel/Palestine?” 41 percent answer “Israel,” 18 percent respond “Palestine,” and 31 percent say “Both.”

In other words, nearly a third of leaders surveyed are confident that it is possible to be simultaneously pro-Israel and pro-Palestine. This flies in the face of the historic, conventional rhetoric on this issue.

To date, many Americans (and by extension U.S. evangelicals) have held to a white hat/black hat/ good guy/bad guy geopolitical understanding of the Middle East. Yet the data seems to indicate that a significant population of U.S. evangelicals are rejecting false dichotomy thinking on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. And this is not true only among evangelical millennials: 64 percent of the survey respondents are age 50 and older. A full 85 perfect are over age 39.

With this in mind, defining “pro-Israel” evangelicals requires some nuance. If we use this stat in a vacuum, lumping the “pro-both” crowd in with the exclusively “pro-Israel,” we can say the dominant majority of U.S. evangelicals are indeed “pro-Israel.” But the “pro-Israel only” set, while still twice as large as the “pro-Palestine only,” constitutes a minority.

In my visits to Israel, I’ve been struck by the widespread, open, and often-heated debates among Israelis on matters related to the conflict there.

So, again: When U.S. evangelicals claim to be “pro-Israel,” what do they mean? For some, it means unquestioning and unwavering support of every current Israeli governmental policy concerning the West Bank and Gaza and an expectation for all U.S. foreign policy to provide the same. They have historical, theological and geopolitical arguments to buttress their case.

But what of the others, including these survey respondents who offer this clarification: “I wholeheartedly support the existence of the Israeli state and her right to defend agreed upon borders. I have legitimate concerns, however, about the impact of current Israeli policies in the Palestinian Territories on the safety, security and dignity of the Palestinian people”?

Does this group get awarded “pro-Israel” status? Or should they be designated something else altogether? Regardless of the verbiage used to describe them, could this group potentially represent a tipping point when it comes to how U.S. evangelicals view their role in addressing the challenges in Israel/Palestine?

I’m learning that being for the Israeli people means listening to, and understanding, their views on the issues directly affecting them. In my numerous visits to Israel, I’ve been struck by the widespread, open, and often-heated debates among Israelis on matters related to the conflict there. But most evangelical pastors don’t know, and have never met, an Israeli, let alone heard his or her unique perspective on the challenges facing their nation’s security and identity. I have met, and continue to meet, Israelis whose friendships matter deeply to me. Their stories shape my understanding of the conflict, their challenges compel me to maintain a learning posture and many of their convictions inspire me.

Can I support the Israeli people in their desire for safety, security and autonomy, and also express reservations about the current state of affairs in the Palestinian Territories? I believe I can and should. No, I don’t think Tehran should get nuclear weapons. No, I don’t believe peace will come without sacrifice among both Israelis and Palestinians. No, I don’t think the status quo in the West Bank is sustainable.

But we’ve been framing the question wrong. Rather than asking “Are you pro-Israel?” we can start asking, “Which vision of Israel’s future are you committing to creating with your voice, your compassion, your service and your faith?”

*Even the language we use to refer the region is problematic. Some refer to the West Bank as the Palestinian Territories, others as Occupied Territories and still others as Judea-Samaria. I’m opting for a common academic usage to refer to both Israel and the Palestinian Territories: “Israel/Palestine.”

 

Steve Norman
Written by
  • marywperry009.wordpress.com/

    Awesome!

  • marywperry009.wordpress.com/

    I don’t believe I have ever read an article which expresses understanding of both sides as well as you do! Thank you sooo much! Have you been to Christ at the Check Point, sponsored by Bethlehem Bible College in Bethlehem. This is where I began learning about the Palestinian (Christians) viewpoint for the first time. Thank you, Thank you, for your excellent article.

    • Alma Ruth

      Hey Mary! My husband was there at CATC 2014!

  • Alma Ruth

    Thank you for a very compassionate approach, especially when it comes, ‘are you pro-Israel’?

  • David

    Thank you for this article. It is very encouraging to seeing a more nuanced view by Evangelical leaders on this issue. I think there has been a lot of education in the past 5 years on the issue when before it was either through ignorance or fear it was avoided. I also grew up not knowing but would consider myself “pro-Israel”. Conferences like ‘Christ at the Checkpoint’ which brought Palestinian, Israeli and internationals together to discuss this, films like ‘With God On our Side’ and brave leaders like Gary Burge, Lynne Hybels have done a lot to bring more education to this issue.

  • richard6272

    Slammin’ at Midnight MadnessMidnight MadnessBy Jadeen SinghA straight bet is merely betting to win or lose.The Timberland sneakers on sale in our online store a large number of people hotspots shoes.Not only Nike shows, you will also discover PUMA shoes, Prada sandals to suit your most need disregarding you are worker’s.Now, we’re trying to do that nationally and that hurts the economy.VerdictA player in this sport will need to move around quickly with fast turns and sharp stops.) So on this post i will give you a little overview of some of my favorite rappers.”Hemos superado todo” ese asunto, comento.The first name in the arena of footwear that is known for its super classy look is the Adidas.Building brand awareness.

    Thats exactly where the name of cat eye originates from.We still haven’t stowed away the Halloween gear.There are so many types of ladies fashion shoes in the market today that you will definitely find one for yourself.89,and Rio Tinto sagged $4.They come in different sizes and designs., 12, and Paris Michael Katherine, 11, and his youngest child, Prince Michael II, 7, known as Blanket, who was carried by a surrogate.You can get the necessary exercise at home doing a little longer, a little faster walk around the block, for example, or take up your own version of high intensity interval training (HIIT) using very simple tools like an exercise ball.Saddened by this, he told the boy to take a long holiday and go and visit his parents.

    Si tratta di un risultato straordinario poiche questo abbozzo di struttura neuronale, praticamente un inizio di cervello, e stato anche in grado di rispondere a una serie di stimoli e di domande.In addition to this, more than 50% of online customers say they spend less than 5 percent of their monthly spending online and 29 % say they spend somewhere between 6 to 10 percent.I think the Knicks are using Tracy McGrady as a pawn to attract players such as LeBron James.while maybe some of these women stories are not entirely credible,You only have 18 summers, you know or soon they be driving you around or I miss when they were small and making gigantic messes with LEGOs.Made Just For YouBehindhand of which bootie is selected, I begin that the shoe cinched up altogether and provided accomplished fit admitting its modularity.

    At a young age, there is no need to use weight and put unnecessary strain on their joints and muscles.It takes a few years for a team to develop.leather-based-based totes Benefiting from a particular luxurious-products desire for foods items in accessory for higher earnings related to Western clients, overseas high high top notch retailers are reality prepared to deal an excellent negotiate a lot extra than inside of any marketplaces for precisely the same goods.Adidas Mat Wizard 4 Wrestling Shoes are now available for pre order.The first type is the Nike free Women’s Training Series.Nike sports kit for Apple iPod nanoWhen released neither Nike dunks nor Nike Dunk SB cost so much as they do today; the resounding success, each time they are released made the entire supply chain sit up and mull over increasing their cost looking at the potential Nike Dunk SB was capable of selling at.

    This will provide a stable base that does not hold water which will provide a longer life for your shed floor.It is the reputable title in supplying sporting equipments to all disciplines.Nike Air Jordan zapatillas de deporte es sin duda una empresa emblemtica, junto con discutiblemente ms famosa en comparacin con Nike, dentro de las caractersticas que acaba de seleccionar.The back again of the watch has links that can be custom-made to match the wrist more snugly for individuals with a more compact wrist.There suggest that economic the display more leaves, and the rights of NG La will result in heavy board leaf decrease.Mine worked great right out of the box.Various games and activities subtly improve their maths skills without them even knowing.

    In the above example if a searcher typed the keywords ‘cheap laptops’ all instances of the words cheap and laptops in your ad would appear in bold.Hopefully, this material will help a person make the most efficient decision on loved ones.The Air Max Tailwind 4 was originally developed for gamers like Moses Malone as well as Jeff Ruland.Something is keeping him in your life and those feelings play a big part in that process.No obstante, la juez Lind considera que los retrasos en el caso de Manning, sospechoso de la mayor filtracion de secretos de la historia de Estados Unidos, han sido los razonables, en un procedimiento tan complejo como este.but you will be as multicultural because the basis for Locker.DO offer special deals just for subscribers.

  • Stephen Corbin

    Regardless of how the survey results break down, there is a strong evangelical arm that are Zionists and believe with all of their soul that the Israelis are destined to dominate all of Israel-Palestine with the Palestinans being driven from their homelands or imprisoned in a type of apartheid. This is based on the Bible predictions about the Jews. But the Jews of the Bible and the modern Israelis are not exactly the same thing. In Biblical times, the Hebrews were a tribe. Over the millennia, they have distributed around the world as a diaspora. Yes, Israel is essentially a Jewish state, although there are non-Jews living in Israel proper. But,
    Israel is not where all Jews live.