Pope Benedict XVI, the great

Uncredited AP In this photo provided by the Vatican newspaper L’Osservatore Romano, Pope Benedict XVI delivers his blessing during his … Continued

Uncredited

AP

In this photo provided by the Vatican newspaper L’Osservatore Romano, Pope Benedict XVI delivers his blessing during his last Angelus noon prayer, from the window of his studio overlooking St. Peter’s Square, at the Vatican, Sunday, Feb. 24, 2013.

While Pope Benedict was visiting the U.S. in 2008, I was doing a radio interview during which I was asked the standard questions about the pope’s personality and how he compared to John Paul II. I tried to give an appropriate sound bite, but I went on a little too long. The radio interviewer cut me off and ended the segment by saying, “Well, I think everyone wishes we had John Paul II back.”

That seems to be the conventional wisdom now that Benedict XVI’s papacy is ending. While people look at Benedict with respect, they really loved John Paul II. Surveys confirm this attitude among most rank and file Catholics.

And so, while Benedict has served in the Chair of Peter for almost eight years, he still is leaving under John Paul’s shadow.

In my teaching and writing, I always try to challenge conventional wisdom—usually in the self-important way that professors are prone to do. But in this case, I can honestly say that I prefer Benedict XVI’s papacy to John Paul II’s.

Here’s why.

Karol Wojtyla was elected to the papacy when I was beginning high school. He had a dramatic flair from the start and soon my bedroom wall was covered with his pictures—he was the Catholic equivalent of Elvis.

As I got older, I actually began to read his writings. Although I struggled with his complex philosophizing, I learned much from it. But what always impressed me most about John Paul was the mystical core of his spirituality: his Marian devotion, his love of the cross, and his underlying sense of the movement of God’s purpose over and through time.

Mystics can make impressive philosophers. Mystics also become great saints—as John Paul most certainly will. But they often are not best suited to the mundane administrative tasks of office. It was during John Paul II’s pontificate that the horrific scandal of the Legion of Christ reached a level of seriousness that could no longer be ignored. But ignored it was, and this was due in part to the fact that the order’s founder, Marcial Maciel Degollado, was a personal friend of John Paul’s. Mysticism can produce remarkable insights into the human condition, but it can also lead to naïveté and credulity.

The appointment of bishops under John Paul’s tenure also left much to be desired. John Paul insisted upon full conformity to the teaching authority of the church. While any pope would also insist upon the same qualities, the difficulty is that any commitment to orthodoxy must be informed by appropriate pastoral discernment—which is to say simply that there is an interpersonal quality to how a bishop should exercise his teaching office. But in the Western world, John Paul’s tenure was marked by an increasing distance of bishops from diocesan laity and by growing disputes over proper governance of the church on a local level.

When he was elected in 2005, Joseph Ratzinger inherited many of these problems. And many of them persist, particularly a dysfunctional Vatican bureaucracy. But to his credit, as Benedict XVI he did move to pursue the case against the Marcial Maciel and to investigate the Legion of Christ. The Pope has also spoken about the “humiliation of the church,” which is a far more open admission of the true nature of the sexual abuse scandal than was ever made during John Paul’s pontificate. Clearly, there is much work to be done, and it is also the case that early on, both as a bishop and a cardinal, Joseph Ratzinger failed to realize the extent of the crisis. But as Pope, Benedict has shown an ability to honestly grapple with the implications of the crisis, and many of the bishops and cardinals he has appointed have done so as well.

Benedict’s writings do not have the imaginative flair found in John Paul’s phenomenological investigations. But they have a clarity that forthrightly engages crucial questions of our time: the role of authority, the nature of truth, and the possibility of faith and hope. I do not agree with some of Benedict’s most dire assessments of our current age or the human condition. But I will say that his theology has prompted me to radically rethink my conventional assumptions about the continuing relevance of the Christian faith. Benedict’s encyclicals demand attention–and multiple readings–but by engaging them carefully, I have found a remarkably challenging teacher and dialogue partner. I find it particularly revealing that both Catholic conservatives and liberals have found much to criticize about Benedict and his papacy. Clearly, his theology and his personality call us to envision different configurations of the Catholic faith than are attractive to the most ideologically driven groups of Catholics in the Western world.

Benedict has also revolutionized the papacy in a different but no less significant way than John Paul II. As I have written numerous times, I was always struck by how Benedict included the bishop’s mitre on his coat of arms. I always understood this as a more humble interpretation of the papacy, especially when compared to associations that come with the imperious and regal tiara that is the usual symbol of the pope. Benedict has sometimes cut a rather uncomfortable figure on the international stage, but he placed his faith in the power of ideas rather than the power of his personality.

Catholics may long for a figure like John Paul II who joins the force of personality with the force of ideas. But all too often the force of personality comes to dominate and shut out everything else. Benedict XVI was particularly aware of this dynamic. Sometimes a human-sized Pope can provide a refreshing challenge to our expectations, as well as an important counter-balance to the larger-than -life quality of the papacy itself.

About

Mathew N. Schmalz Mathew N. Schmalz is Associate Professor of Religious Studies at The College of the Holy Cross.
Comments are closed.

Read More Articles

Valle Header Art
My Life Depended on the Very Act of Writing

How I was saved by writing about God and cancer.

shutterstock_188545496
Sociologist: Religion Can Predict Sexual Behavior

“Religion and sex are tracking each other like never before,” says sociologist Mark Regnerus.

5783999789_9d06e5d7df_b
The Internet Is Not Killing Religion. So What Is?

Why is religion in decline in the modern world? And what can save it?

river dusk
Cleaner, Lighter, Closer

What’s a fella got to do to be baptized?

shutterstock_188022491
Magical Thinking and the Canonization of Two Popes

Why Pope Francis is canonizing two popes for all of the world wide web to see.

987_00
An Ayatollah’s Gift to Baha’is, Iran’s Largest Religious Minority

An ayatollah offers a beautiful symbolic gesture against a backdrop of violent persecution.

Screenshot 2014-04-23 11.40.54
Atheists Bad, Christians Good: A Review of “God’s Not Dead”

A smug Christian movie about smug atheists leads to an inevitable happy ending.

shutterstock_134310734
Ten Ways to Make Your Church Autism-Friendly

The author of the Church of England’s autism guidelines shares advice any church can follow.

Pile_of_trash_2
Pope Francis: Stop the Culture of Waste

What is the human cost of our tendency to throw away?

chapel door
“Sometimes You Find Something Quiet and Holy”: A New York Story

In a hidden, underground sanctuary, we were all together for a few minutes in this sweet and holy mystery.

shutterstock_178468880
Mary Magdalene, the Closest Friend of Jesus

She’s been ignored, dismissed, and misunderstood. But the story of Easter makes it clear that Mary was Jesus’ most faithful friend.

sunset-hair
From Passover to Easter: Why I’m Grateful to be Jewish, Christian, and Alive

Passover with friends. Easter with family. It’s almost enough to make you believe in God.

colbert
Top 10 Reasons We’re Glad A Catholic Colbert Is Taking Over Letterman’s “Late Show”

How might we love Stephen Colbert as the “Late Show” host? Let us count the ways.

emptytomb
God’s Not Dead? Why the Good News Is Better than That

The resurrection of Jesus is not a matter of private faith — it’s a proclamation for the whole world.

shutterstock_186795503
The Three Most Surprising Things Jesus Said

Think you know Jesus? Some of his sayings may surprise you.

egg.jpg
Jesus, Bunnies, and Colored Eggs: An Explanation of Holy Week and Easter

So, Easter is a one-day celebration of Jesus rising from the dead and turning into a bunny, right? Not exactly.